Love In Every Detail 💝 Shop Valentine's Day

January Birthday Gift Ideas ❤️ Explore the Gift Guide

Find your spark! ⚡ Book your permanent jewelry appointment now!

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Under $75

Clear filters
Trilogy Tiny Stud Earrings

Trilogy Tiny Stud Earrings

$38.00

13 colors
  • +9 more
Flat Point Farm Goat Milk Soap

Flat Point Farm Goat Milk Soap

$12.00

Full Circle Pendulum Earring

Full Circle Pendulum Earring

$56.00

12 colors
  • +8 more
Handmade Martha's Vineyard Keepsake Bowl

Handmade Martha's Vineyard Keepsake Bowl

$42.00

2 colors
Recycled Flip Flop Bangle Bracelet, Set of 12

Recycled Flip Flop Bangle Bracelet, Set of 12

$16.00

Jewelry Box Gift Wrapping

Jewelry Box Gift Wrapping

$7.00

Gold Leaf or Silver Leaf Petite Cluster Earrings

Gold Leaf or Silver Leaf Petite Cluster Earrings

$58.00

2 materials
Full Circle Triple Circle Earrings

Full Circle Triple Circle Earrings

$62.00

16 colors
  • +12 more
Gold Leaf Fringe Earrings w/ Antique Triangles

Gold Leaf Fringe Earrings w/ Antique Triangles

$64.00

6 colors
  • +2 more
Martha's Vineyard Bangle Bracelet, Brass, SALE
31% off

Martha's Vineyard Bangle Bracelet, Brass, SALE

$42.00 $29.00 31% off

Mini Crossbody Wristlet Clutch

Mini Crossbody Wristlet Clutch

$44.00

19 colors
  • +15 more
Sticker, Martha's Vineyard With Heart

Sticker, Martha's Vineyard With Heart

$4.00

Sticker, Martha's Vineyard With Rainbow

Sticker, Martha's Vineyard With Rainbow

$4.00

2 colors
Lucky Hoop Earrings

Lucky Hoop Earrings

$58.00

2 colors
Sticker, Martha's Vineyard Mermaid

Sticker, Martha's Vineyard Mermaid

$4.00

One Hundred Blessings, Handmade Gift Package of Proverbs, Sayings and Wisdom

One Hundred Blessings, Handmade Gift Package of Proverbs, Sayings and Wisdom

$24.00

Leather Eyeglass Case with Frame Design

Leather Eyeglass Case with Frame Design

$32.00

19 colors
  • +15 more
Repair Fee, Custom Fee, Earring Replacement Fee, $30

Repair Fee, Custom Fee, Earring Replacement Fee, $30

$30.00

White Mother of Pearl Oval Drop Earrings, SALE
18% off

White Mother of Pearl Oval Drop Earrings, SALE

$39.00 $32.00 18% off

Gemstone Roll-On Perfume Oil, 1/8 oz. Fragrance

Gemstone Roll-On Perfume Oil, 1/8 oz. Fragrance

$59.00

6mm white pearl stud earrings sterling silver back

Freshwater Pearl Stud Earrings, Small, 6mm, Sterling

$39.00

5 colors
  • +1 more
Martha's Vineyard Bangle Bracelet, Silver, SALE
31% off

Martha's Vineyard Bangle Bracelet, Silver, SALE

$42.00 $29.00 31% off

Statement Earrings, Drop on Circle Post, Teardrop with Circle

Statement Earrings, Drop on Circle Post, Teardrop with Circle

$72.00

9 colors
  • +5 more
ocean blue vegan leather wallet wristlet and crossbody clutch on white background
ocean blue vegan leather wristlet wallet clutch and crossbody on whitebackground

Karina Convertible Wristlet & Wallet

$62.00

18 colors
  • +14 more
Handmade Martha's Vineyard Pottery Ornament

Handmade Martha's Vineyard Pottery Ornament

$24.00

2 colors
Martha’s Vineyard Sea Salt, 3 pack

Martha’s Vineyard Sea Salt, 3 pack

$20.00

Wisdom Box, Matchbox Gift Package of Proverbs, Sayings and Wisdom

Wisdom Box, Matchbox Gift Package of Proverbs, Sayings and Wisdom

$21.00

Swag Hoops

Swag Hoops

$62.00

5 colors
  • +1 more
Kayleigh Side Pocket Bucket Bag

Kayleigh Side Pocket Bucket Bag

$74.00

20 colors
  • +16 more
Mini Tote, Textured Rope Handle

Mini Tote, Textured Rope Handle

$54.00

8 colors
  • +4 more
Petite Leaf Earrings

Petite Leaf Earrings

$48.00

7 colors
  • +3 more
Chunky Pearl Drop Earrings

Chunky Pearl Drop Earrings

$48.00

5 colors
  • +1 more
Teal Swirl Glass Beaded Crystal Dangle Earrings

Teal Swirl Glass Beaded Crystal Dangle Earrings

$42.00

15 colors
  • +11 more
Hobo Handbag

Hobo Handbag

$74.00

18 colors
  • +14 more
Circle Drop Earrings, Crystal Quartz with Gold
Circle Drop Earrings, Crystal Quartz with Silver

Circle Drop Earrings, Crystal Quartz with Silver or Gold

from $54.00

2 materials
Multicolor Rainbow Beaded Bracelet for Kids, Child Size Trilogy Bracelet
Ocean Blues Glass Beaded Bracelet Kids Sizing with Sterling Silver Bright and colorful beaded bracelet on white background

Multicolor Rainbow Beaded Bracelet for Kids, Child Size Trilogy Bracelet

$49.00

2 colors
Permanent Jewelry Appointment Time Slot, Deposit Towards Jewelry

Permanent Jewelry Appointment Time Slot, Deposit Towards Jewelry

$40.00

Full Circle Large Clip On Earring

Full Circle Large Clip On Earring

$46.00

10 colors
  • +6 more
Gilded Oyster Jewelry Dish, Natural

Gilded Oyster Jewelry Dish, Natural

$44.00

Body & Hair Bar, Made in Massachusetts

Body & Hair Bar, Made in Massachusetts

$12.00

Load more