$5 off $50, $10 off $100, $20 off $200 THIS WEEKEND ONLY | Discount Automatically Applied At Checkout

DECEMBER BIRTHDAY GIFT GUIDE 🩵

PERMANENT JEWELRY ⚡ Book Your Appointment Here

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Under $75

Clear filters
Sky Blue Rectangle Glass Drop Earrings on 14k Gold Fill Leverback with Crystal Accent

Sky Blue Rectangle Crystal Dangle Drop Earrings, on 14k Gold Fill, Trilogy

$46.00

1 color
Martha's Vineyard Charm
New

Martha's Vineyard Charm

from $58.00

2 jewelry materials
Mosaic Crystal Stud Earrings, Assorted

Mosaic Crystal Stud Earrings, Assorted

from $45.00

MV Sea Salt, Hostess Jar

MV Sea Salt, Hostess Jar

$34.00

Upcycled Cashmere Wrist Warmers

Upcycled Cashmere Wrist Warmers

$46.00

6 colors
  • +1 more
Sterling Silver Adjustable Mermaid Ring

Sterling Silver Adjustable Mermaid Ring

$72.00

Amazonite Circle Drop Earrings

Amazonite Circle Drop Earrings

from $54.00

2 materials
Beaded Coin Pouch

Beaded Coin Pouch

from $29.00

Martha's Vineyard Pendant Necklace Stamp of Island on circle white background

Martha's Vineyard Island, 18" MV Charm Pendant Necklace, 3/8" Diameter (smaller)

from $69.00

2 jewelry materials
Amethyst Crystal Heart Keepsake

Amethyst Crystal Heart Keepsake

$30.00

Mosaic Crystal Stud Earrings

Mosaic Crystal Stud Earrings

$49.00

Initial Letter Charms
New

Initial Letter Charms

from $24.00

2 jewelry materials
Freshwater Pearl Stud Earrings, Large, 10mm, Sterling Silver

Freshwater Pearl Stud Earrings, Large, 10mm, Sterling Silver

$59.00

4 colors
Desert Sky Bracelet, Sky Blue Glass Rectangle Beaded Bracelet on Gold
Sky Blue Glass Rectangle Beaded Bracelet on Gold

Desert Sky Bracelet, Sky Blue Glass Rectangle Beaded Bracelet on Gold

$69.00

Mini Martha's Vineyard Charm
New

Mini Martha's Vineyard Charm

from $42.00

2 jewelry materials
Martha's Vineyard gold vermeil tiny stud earrings

Martha's Vineyard Tiny Stud Earrings

from $38.00

2 jewelry materials
Coin Pearl Charm

Coin Pearl Charm

$52.00

2 jewelry materials
Tree Handcrafted Fused Glass Holiday Ornament
New

Tree Handcrafted Fused Glass Holiday Ornament

$24.00

3 colors
White Martha's Vineyard Glass Charm

White Martha's Vineyard Glass Charm

$48.00

8 colors
  • +3 more
Magnet, Martha's Vineyard With Rainbow

Magnet, Martha's Vineyard With Rainbow

$6.00

2 colors
Stefanie Wolf Designs Marthas vineyard jewelry gift card in front of hydrangeas in hand

Stefanie Wolf Designs Gift Card

from $10.00

Full Circle Small Stud Clip On Earring

Full Circle Small Stud Clip On Earring

$42.00

12 colors
  • +7 more
Crystal Quartz Wishbone Earrings

Crystal Quartz Wishbone Earrings

$62.00

Sea Glass Slide Bracelet

Sea Glass Slide Bracelet

$52.00

Oyster Shell Charm
gold vermeil oyster charm on delicate gold chain necklace
New

Oyster Shell Charm

from $56.00

2 jewelry materials
Light Blue Crystal Charm

Light Blue Crystal Charm

$12.00

14 colors
  • +9 more
Blue Sea Glass Sterling Silver Stacking Ring
New

Blue Sea Glass Sterling Silver Stacking Ring

from $72.00

2 jewelry materials
Mother of Pearl Scallop Shell Charm

Mother of Pearl Scallop Shell Charm

$42.00

2 jewelry materials
Colorful Enamel Gold Necklace
New

Colorful Enamel Gold Necklace

$64.00

5 colors
Round Swirly Shiva Shell Charm
pearl charm necklace with charms on marble background

Round Swirly Shiva Shell Charm

$32.00

2 jewelry materials
Teardrop Huggie Hoop Earrings Sterling Silver on white background

Teardrop Huggie Hoop Earrings

from $54.00

2 materials
Martha's Vineyard Sterling Silver Tiny Ring

Martha's Vineyard Island Sterling Silver Ring

$58.00

1 jewelry material, 7 sizes
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
Handmade Leather Martha’s Vineyard Keychain, Locally Made

Handmade Leather Martha’s Vineyard Keychain, Locally Made

$22.00

Colorful Leather Double Sided Credit Card Holder

Colorful Leather Double Sided Credit Card Holder

$39.00

7 colors
  • +2 more
Classic Hoop Earrings, Hinged 18-19mm
Sold out

Classic Hoop Earrings, Hinged 18-19mm

from $42.00

2 materials
Petite Scallop Shell Charm
New

Petite Scallop Shell Charm

from $24.00

2 jewelry materials
Seaglass 3D Ornament
New

Seaglass 3D Ornament

$32.00

4 colors
Starfish Charm
New

Starfish Charm

$28.00

2 jewelry materials
Jewelry Extender Chain

Jewelry Extender Chain

$29.00

2 colors
Tiny White Freshwater Pearl Charm
New

Tiny White Freshwater Pearl Charm

$20.00

2 jewelry materials
Load more