FREE SHIPPING on orders $125+

PERMANENT JEWELRY ⚡ Book Your Appointment Here

September Gift Guide 💙 Shop September Gifts

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Under $50

Clear filters
Handmade Martha's Vineyard Keepsake Bowl

Handmade Martha's Vineyard Keepsake Bowl

$42.00

2 colors
Mini Crossbody Wristlet Clutch

Mini Crossbody Wristlet Clutch

$48.00

19 colors
  • +14 more
Leather Eyeglass Case with Frame Design

Leather Eyeglass Case with Frame Design

$39.00

17 colors
  • +12 more
Permanent Jewelry Appointment Time Slot, Deposit Towards Jewelry

Permanent Jewelry Appointment Time Slot, Deposit Towards Jewelry

$40.00

Freshwater Pearl Stud Earrings, Small, 6mm, Sterling

Freshwater Pearl Stud Earrings, Small, 6mm, Sterling

$39.00

5 colors
Colorful Enamel Gold Bracelet
Blue Vermeil Enamel Gold Braacelet
New

Colorful Enamel Gold Bracelet

$48.00

5 colors
Chunky Pearl Drop Earrings

Chunky Pearl Drop Earrings

$48.00

8 colors
  • +3 more
Leather Card Case

Leather Card Case

$34.00

7 colors
  • +2 more
Mini Martha's Vineyard Charm

Mini Martha's Vineyard Charm

from $42.00

2 jewelry materials
White Freshwater Pearl + Chain Drop Charm

White Freshwater Pearl + Chain Drop Charm

$38.00

3 colors
Full Circle Large Clip On Earring

Full Circle Large Clip On Earring

$46.00

10 colors
  • +5 more
Gilded Oyster Jewelry Dish, Natural

Gilded Oyster Jewelry Dish, Natural

$44.00

Teal Swirl Glass Beaded Crystal Dangle Earrings

Teal Swirl Glass Beaded Crystal Dangle Earrings

$42.00

15 colors
  • +10 more
Martha's Vineyard Oyster Jewelry Dish, Collaboration with Grit and Grace and Laura Lobdell

Martha's Vineyard Oyster Jewelry Dish, Collaboration with Grit and Grace and Laura Lobdell

$49.00

Pair of pearl 8mm white freshwater stud earrings on a white background

Freshwater Pearl Stud Earrings, Medium, 8mm, Sterling

$49.00

4 colors
Petite Scallop Shell Charm
New

Petite Scallop Shell Charm

from $24.00

2 jewelry materials
Starfish Charm

Starfish Charm

$28.00

2 jewelry materials
MV Sea Salt, Hostess Jar

MV Sea Salt, Hostess Jar

$34.00

Sky Blue Rectangle Crystal Dangle Drop Earrings, on 14k Gold Fill, Trilogy

Sky Blue Rectangle Crystal Dangle Drop Earrings, on 14k Gold Fill, Trilogy

$46.00

1 color
Seaglass Tree Holiday Ornament, 3D
New

Seaglass Tree Holiday Ornament, 3D

$32.00

4 colors
White Martha's Vineyard Glass Charm

White Martha's Vineyard Glass Charm

$48.00

8 colors
  • +3 more
Scallop Shell Charm, Mother of Pearl

Scallop Shell Charm, Mother of Pearl

$42.00

2 jewelry materials
Full Circle Small Stud Clip On Earring

Full Circle Small Stud Clip On Earring

$42.00

12 colors
  • +7 more
Amethyst Crystal Heart Keepsake

Amethyst Crystal Heart Keepsake

$30.00

Pink tote bag with oyster illustrations and "shuck the patriarchy" text on a white background
New

Oyster Tote Bag - Shuck the Patriarchy

$32.00

2 colors
Handmade Leather Martha’s Vineyard Keychain, Locally Made

Handmade Leather Martha’s Vineyard Keychain, Locally Made

$28.00

Jewelry Extender Chain

Jewelry Extender Chain

$29.00

2 colors
Scallop Shell Charm
New

Scallop Shell Charm

from $48.00

2 jewelry materials
Mini Mother of Pearl Martha's Vineyard Island Charm

Mini Mother of Pearl Martha's Vineyard Island Charm

$42.00

2 jewelry materials
Mother of Pearl Cross Charm
New

Mother of Pearl Cross Charm

$32.00

2 jewelry materials
White Freshwater Pearl Charm

White Freshwater Pearl Charm

$32.00

2 jewelry materials
Hydrangea Blue Martha's Vineyard Glass Charm

Hydrangea Blue Martha's Vineyard Glass Charm

$48.00

8 colors
  • +3 more
Flower Stud Earrings, Aster

Flower Stud Earrings, Aster

$40.00

2 colors
Mini Tree Seaglass Ornament
New

Mini Tree Seaglass Ornament

$28.00

3 colors
Shark Bite Beaded Coin Pouch
New

Shark Bite Beaded Coin Pouch

$39.00

Martha's Vineyard Coin Charm, Small (3/8" diameter)

Martha's Vineyard Coin Charm, Small (3/8" diameter)

from $42.00

2 jewelry materials
Pink Freshwater Pearl Charm

Pink Freshwater Pearl Charm

$32.00

2 jewelry materials
Turquoise Glass Beaded Teardrop Earrings

Turquoise Glass Beaded Teardrop Earrings

$46.00

13 colors
  • +8 more
Color Wave Jewelry Tray, Martha's Vineyard

Color Wave Jewelry Tray, Martha's Vineyard

$42.00

3 colors
A brass ring with a hanging ticket charm engraved with a flying horses carousel horse and the words 'FREE RIDE' on a plain white background.
A vintage brass ring with a hanging tag engraved with 'FLYING HORSES CAROUSEL - Oak Bluffs - 150'.
Sold out

Brass Ring Charm Flying Horses Carousel | 150th Anniversary Free Ride Ticket

$42.00

Handsewn Book, Friendship

Handsewn Book, Friendship

$28.00

Tiny Sideways Heart Charm

Tiny Sideways Heart Charm

$32.00

2 jewelry materials
Blue Freshwater Pearl Charm
New

Blue Freshwater Pearl Charm

$32.00

2 jewelry materials
Royal Blue Glass Beaded Teardrop Earrings

Royal Blue Glass Beaded Teardrop Earrings

$46.00

13 colors
  • +8 more
Crystal Quartz Earrings, Limited Edition Crystal Clarity Collection

Crystal Quartz Earrings, Limited Edition Crystal Clarity Collection

$49.00

Royal Blue Evil Eye Glass Charm

Royal Blue Evil Eye Glass Charm

$28.00

2 jewelry materials
Flower Drop Earrings, Limited Edition
Sold out

Flower Drop Earrings, Limited Edition

$49.00

2 colors
Pearl Ice Cream Cone Charm
Sold out

Pearl Ice Cream Cone Charm

from $32.00

2 jewelry materials
Royal Blue glass and crystal sterling silver earrings on white background

Royal Blue Glass Beaded Crystal Dangle Earrings

$42.00

15 colors
  • +10 more
Red Glass Beaded Crystal Dangle Earrings

Red Glass Beaded Crystal Dangle Earrings

$42.00

15 colors
  • +10 more
Load more