FREE SHIPPING on orders $125+

Permanent Jewelry | Book Your Appointment Here

November Gift Guide | Shop November Gifts

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Under $50
Clear filters
Handmade Martha's Vineyard Keepsake Bowl
Handmade Martha's Vineyard Keepsake Bowl

Handmade Martha's Vineyard Keepsake Bowl

$42.00

2 colors
Mini Crossbody Wristlet Clutch
Mini Crossbody Wristlet Clutch

Mini Crossbody Wristlet Clutch

$48.00

19 colors
Leather Eyeglass Case with Frame Design
Leather Eyeglass Case with Frame Design

Leather Eyeglass Case with Frame Design

$39.00

18 colors
Permanent Jewelry Appointment Time Slot, Deposit Towards Jewelry
Permanent Jewelry Appointment Time Slot, Deposit Towards Jewelry

Permanent Jewelry Appointment Time Slot, Deposit Towards Jewelry

$40.00

Freshwater Pearl Stud Earrings, Small, 6mm, Sterling
Freshwater Pearl Stud Earrings, Small, 6mm, Sterling

Freshwater Pearl Stud Earrings, Small, 6mm, Sterling

$39.00

5 colors
Initial Letter Charms
Initial Letter Charms
New

Initial Letter Charms

from $28.00

2 jewelry materials
Chunky Pearl Drop Earrings
Chunky Pearl Drop Earrings

Chunky Pearl Drop Earrings

$48.00

7 colors
Leather Card Case
Leather Card Case

Leather Card Case

$34.00

8 colors
Mini Martha's Vineyard Charm
Mini Martha's Vineyard Charm

Mini Martha's Vineyard Charm

from $42.00

2 jewelry materials
White Freshwater Pearl + Chain Drop Charm
White Freshwater Pearl + Chain Drop Charm

White Freshwater Pearl + Chain Drop Charm

$38.00

3 colors
Full Circle Large Clip On Earring
Full Circle Large Clip On Earring

Full Circle Large Clip On Earring

$46.00

10 colors
Seaglass Tree Holiday Ornament, 3D
Seaglass Tree Holiday Ornament, 3D
New

Seaglass Tree Holiday Ornament, 3D

$32.00

4 colors
Gilded Oyster Jewelry Dish, Natural
Gilded Oyster Jewelry Dish, Natural

Gilded Oyster Jewelry Dish, Natural

$44.00

Teal Swirl Glass Beaded Crystal Dangle Earrings
Teal Swirl Glass Beaded Crystal Dangle Earrings

Teal Swirl Glass Beaded Crystal Dangle Earrings

$42.00

15 colors
Martha's Vineyard Oyster Jewelry Dish, Collaboration with Grit and Grace and Laura Lobdell
Martha's Vineyard Oyster Jewelry Dish, Collaboration with Grit and Grace and Laura Lobdell

Martha's Vineyard Oyster Jewelry Dish, Collaboration with Grit and Grace and Laura Lobdell

$49.00

Pair of pearl 8mm white freshwater stud earrings on a white background
Freshwater Pearl Stud Earrings, Medium, 8mm, Sterling

Freshwater Pearl Stud Earrings, Medium, 8mm, Sterling

$49.00

4 colors
Petite Scallop Shell Charm
Petite Scallop Shell Charm
New

Petite Scallop Shell Charm

from $24.00

2 jewelry materials
Good Energy Perfume Oil 10 ml
New

Good Energy Perfume Oil 10 ml

$48.00

Starfish Charm
Starfish Charm

Starfish Charm

$28.00

2 jewelry materials
MV Sea Salt, Hostess Jar
MV Sea Salt, Hostess Jar

MV Sea Salt, Hostess Jar

$34.00

Sky Blue Rectangle Crystal Dangle Drop Earrings, on 14k Gold Fill, Trilogy

Sky Blue Rectangle Crystal Dangle Drop Earrings, on 14k Gold Fill, Trilogy

$46.00

1 color
Scallop Shell Charm, Mother of Pearl
Scallop Shell Charm, Mother of Pearl

Scallop Shell Charm, Mother of Pearl

$42.00

2 jewelry materials
White Martha's Vineyard Glass Charm
White Martha's Vineyard Glass Charm

White Martha's Vineyard Glass Charm

$48.00

8 colors
Full Circle Small Stud Clip On Earring
Full Circle Small Stud Clip On Earring

Full Circle Small Stud Clip On Earring

$42.00

12 colors
Jewelry Extender Chain
Jewelry Extender Chain

Jewelry Extender Chain

$29.00

2 colors
Amethyst Crystal Heart Keepsake
Amethyst Crystal Heart Keepsake

Amethyst Crystal Heart Keepsake

$30.00

Pink tote bag with oyster illustrations and "shuck the patriarchy" text on a white background
Oyster Tote Bag - Shuck the Patriarchy
New

Oyster Tote Bag - Shuck the Patriarchy

$32.00

2 colors
Handmade Leather Martha’s Vineyard Keychain, Locally Made
Handmade Leather Martha’s Vineyard Keychain, Locally Made

Handmade Leather Martha’s Vineyard Keychain, Locally Made

$28.00

Scallop Shell Charm
Scallop Shell Charm
New

Scallop Shell Charm

from $48.00

2 jewelry materials
Mini Tree Seaglass Ornament
Mini Tree Seaglass Ornament
New

Mini Tree Seaglass Ornament

$28.00

3 colors
Mother of Pearl Cross Charm
Mother of Pearl Cross Charm
New

Mother of Pearl Cross Charm

$32.00

2 jewelry materials
Mini Mother of Pearl Martha's Vineyard Island Charm
Mini Mother of Pearl Martha's Vineyard Island Charm

Mini Mother of Pearl Martha's Vineyard Island Charm

$42.00

2 jewelry materials
White Freshwater Pearl Charm
White Freshwater Pearl Charm

White Freshwater Pearl Charm

$32.00

2 jewelry materials
Shark Bite Beaded Coin Pouch
New

Shark Bite Beaded Coin Pouch

$39.00

Hydrangea Blue Martha's Vineyard Glass Charm
Hydrangea Blue Martha's Vineyard Glass Charm

Hydrangea Blue Martha's Vineyard Glass Charm

$48.00

8 colors
Flower Stud Earrings, Aster
Flower Stud Earrings, Aster

Flower Stud Earrings, Aster

$40.00

2 colors
A brass ring with a hanging ticket charm engraved with a flying horses carousel horse and the words 'FREE RIDE' on a plain white background.
A vintage brass ring with a hanging tag engraved with 'FLYING HORSES CAROUSEL - Oak Bluffs - 150'.
New

Brass Ring Charm Flying Horses Carousel | 150th Anniversary Free Ride Ticket

$42.00

Martha's Vineyard Coin Charm, Small (3/8" diameter)
Martha's Vineyard Coin Charm, Small (3/8" diameter)

Martha's Vineyard Coin Charm, Small (3/8" diameter)

from $42.00

2 jewelry materials
Pink Freshwater Pearl Charm
Pink Freshwater Pearl Charm

Pink Freshwater Pearl Charm

$32.00

2 jewelry materials
Turquoise Glass Beaded Teardrop Earrings

Turquoise Glass Beaded Teardrop Earrings

$46.00

13 colors
Load more