20% off SITEWIDE 🎆 Treat Yourself in the New Year

January Birthday Gift Ideas ❤️ Explore the Gift Guide

Find your spark! ⚡ Book your permanent jewelry appointment now!

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Under $25

Clear filters
Flat Point Farm Goat Milk Soap

Flat Point Farm Goat Milk Soap

$12.00

Recycled Flip Flop Bangle Bracelet, Set of 12

Recycled Flip Flop Bangle Bracelet, Set of 12

$16.00

Sticker, Martha's Vineyard With Heart

Sticker, Martha's Vineyard With Heart

$4.00

Sticker, Martha's Vineyard With Rainbow

Sticker, Martha's Vineyard With Rainbow

$4.00

2 colors
Sticker, Martha's Vineyard Mermaid

Sticker, Martha's Vineyard Mermaid

$4.00

One Hundred Blessings, Handmade Gift Package of Proverbs, Sayings and Wisdom

One Hundred Blessings, Handmade Gift Package of Proverbs, Sayings and Wisdom

$24.00

Handmade Martha's Vineyard Pottery Ornament

Handmade Martha's Vineyard Pottery Ornament

$24.00

2 colors
Martha’s Vineyard Sea Salt, 3 pack

Martha’s Vineyard Sea Salt, 3 pack

$20.00

Wisdom Box, Matchbox Gift Package of Proverbs, Sayings and Wisdom

Wisdom Box, Matchbox Gift Package of Proverbs, Sayings and Wisdom

$21.00

Body & Hair Bar, Made in Massachusetts

Body & Hair Bar, Made in Massachusetts

$12.00

Large Makeup Pouch, Cosmetic Case, Toiletry Storage Holder, Organizer, Zippered Travel Bag, in Assorted Colors, SALE,
Sold out

Large Makeup Pouch, Cosmetic Case, Toiletry Storage Holder, Organizer, Zippered Travel Bag, in Assorted Colors, SALE,

$22.00 $14.00 36% off

1 color
Sticker, The World is Your Oyster

Sticker, The World is Your Oyster

$4.00

The World is Your Oyster Handmade Pottery Wishing Stone

The World is Your Oyster Handmade Pottery Wishing Stone

$22.00

3 colors
Petite Charm Connector Lock, Enhancer Clip
New

Petite Charm Connector Lock, Enhancer Clip

from $24.00

Magnet, Martha's Vineyard With Rainbow

Magnet, Martha's Vineyard With Rainbow

$6.00

2 colors
Stefanie Wolf Designs Gift Card

Stefanie Wolf Designs Gift Card

from $10.00

Leather Martha's Vineyard Keychain, Assorted

Leather Martha's Vineyard Keychain, Assorted

$19.00

Light Blue Crystal Charm

Light Blue Crystal Charm

$18.00

12 colors
  • +8 more
Handsewn Book, Friendship
Sold out

Handsewn Book, Friendship

$24.00

Sticker, Wolf with Full Moon

Sticker, Wolf with Full Moon

$4.00

Starfish Charm, 8mm
New

Starfish Charm, 8mm

$24.00

Handmade Book of Simple Graces

Handmade Book of Simple Graces

$24.00

Pink Crystal Charm
New

Pink Crystal Charm

$18.00

12 colors
  • +8 more
Green Crystal Charm
New

Green Crystal Charm

$18.00

12 colors
  • +8 more
Handsewn Book, Courage

Handsewn Book, Courage

$24.00

Light Sky Blue Circle Glass Charm
Sterling Silver Paperclip Chain Necklace with Charm Holder Clasp
New

Light Sky Blue Circle Glass Charm

$24.00

8 colors
  • +4 more
Aqua Crystal Charm
New

Aqua Crystal Charm

$18.00

12 colors
  • +8 more
Hugs and Kisses X O Mismatched Set, Sterling Stud Earrings, SALE
31% off

Hugs and Kisses X O Mismatched Set, Sterling Stud Earrings, SALE

$32.00 $22.00 31% off

Yellow Tiny Crystal Charm
New

Yellow Tiny Crystal Charm

$18.00

12 colors
  • +8 more
Cobalt Blue Crystal Charm
New

Cobalt Blue Crystal Charm

$18.00

12 colors
  • +8 more
Man Bar, Men's Bath Bar, Made in Massachusetts
New

Man Bar, Men's Bath Bar, Made in Massachusetts

$16.00

Tree Handcrafted Fused Glass Holiday Ornament
New

Tree Handcrafted Fused Glass Holiday Ornament

$22.00

3 colors
Handsewn Book, Grace

Handsewn Book, Grace

$24.00

Hand Dyed Boho Cotton Scarf, SALE
Sold out

Hand Dyed Boho Cotton Scarf, SALE

$39.00 $22.00 44% off

12 colors
  • +8 more
Pug Dog Statement Earrings, SALE
Sold out

Pug Dog Statement Earrings, SALE

$32.00 $22.00 31% off

Lavender Tiny Crystal Charm
New

Lavender Tiny Crystal Charm

$18.00

12 colors
  • +8 more
Pink Small Circle Glass Charm
New

Pink Small Circle Glass Charm

$24.00

8 colors
  • +4 more
Emerald Green Crystal Charm
New

Emerald Green Crystal Charm

$18.00

12 colors
  • +8 more
Small Stud Earrings, Spoon and Fork, SALE
31% off

Small Stud Earrings, Spoon and Fork, SALE

$32.00 $22.00 31% off

1 material
Tiny Scallop Shell Ring Dish Handmade Pottery
New

Tiny Scallop Shell Ring Dish, Handmade Pottery

$24.00

Load more