FREE SHIPPING on orders $125+

Permanent Jewelry | Book Your Appointment Here

October Gift Guide | Shop October Gifts

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Buy A Charm Holder, Get 50% Off Charms
Clear filters
Statement Oyster Shell Charm
Statement Oyster Shell Charm
New

Statement Oyster Shell Charm

from $98.00

2 jewelry materials
Nautical Knot Charm
Nautical Knot Charm
New

Nautical Knot Charm

from $82.00

2 jewelry materials
Fish Charm
A close-up of a model wearing a delicate gold chain necklace with a small fish charm and a white pearl charm.
New

Fish Charm

from $62.00

2 jewelry materials
Carved Amazonite Gemstone Fish Charm
Carved Amazonite Gemstone Fish Charm
Sold out

Carved Amazonite Gemstone Fish Charm

$72.00

2 jewelry materials
Carved Green Aventurine Gemstone Fish Charm
Carved Green Aventurine Gemstone Fish Charm
New

Carved Green Aventurine Gemstone Fish Charm

$72.00

2 jewelry materials
Carved Hot Pink Chalcedony Gemstone Fish Charm
Carved Hot Pink Chalcedony Gemstone Fish Charm
New

Carved Hot Pink Chalcedony Gemstone Fish Charm

$72.00

2 jewelry materials
Carved Carnelian Gemstone Fish Charm
Carved Carnelian Gemstone Fish Charm
Sold out

Carved Carnelian Gemstone Fish Charm

$72.00

2 jewelry materials
Carved Aquamarine Gemstone Fish Charm
Carved Aquamarine Gemstone Fish Charm
New

Carved Aquamarine Gemstone Fish Charm

$78.00

2 jewelry materials
Aquamarine & White Topaz Gemstone Pendant, One-Of-A-Kind
New

Aquamarine & White Topaz Gemstone Pendant, One-Of-A-Kind

$128.00

Hibiscus Flower Charm, Mother of Pearl
Hibiscus Flower Charm, Mother of Pearl
New

Hibiscus Flower Charm, Mother of Pearl

$38.00

2 jewelry materials
Brass Ring Pendant Necklace | Flying Horses Carousel 150th Anniversary Free Ride Ticket
A close-up of a model wearing a delicate silver chain necklace with a flying horses brass ring charm
New

Brass Ring Pendant Necklace | Flying Horses Carousel 150th Anniversary Free Ride Ticket

from $114.00

2 jewelry materials
A brass ring with a hanging ticket charm engraved with a flying horses carousel horse and the words 'FREE RIDE' on a plain white background.
A vintage brass ring with a hanging tag engraved with 'FLYING HORSES CAROUSEL - Oak Bluffs - 150'.
New

Brass Ring Charm Flying Horses Carousel | 150th Anniversary Free Ride Ticket

$42.00

Heart shaped gold fill shiva shell charm on white background
Heart shaped sterling silver shiva shell charm on white background
New

Swirly Shell Heart Charm

$32.00

2 jewelry materials
Mother of Pearl Anchor Charm
Mother of Pearl Anchor Charm
New

Mother of Pearl Anchor Charm

$48.00

2 jewelry materials
Carved Flourite Gemstone Fish Charm
Carved Flourite Gemstone Fish Charm
New

Carved Flourite Gemstone Fish Charm

$72.00

2 jewelry materials
Carved Lapis Lazuli Gemstone Fish Charm
Carved Lapis Lazuli Gemstone Fish Charm
New

Carved Lapis Lazuli Gemstone Fish Charm

$72.00

2 jewelry materials
Carved Rainbow Moonstone Gemstone Fish Charm
Carved Rainbow Moonstone Gemstone Fish Charm
New

Carved Rainbow Moonstone Gemstone Fish Charm

$72.00

2 jewelry materials
Carved Labradorite Gemstone Fish Charm
Carved Labradorite Gemstone Fish Charm
New

Carved Labradorite Gemstone Fish Charm

$98.00

2 jewelry materials
Pearl Cross Charm
Pearl Cross Charm
Sold out

Pearl Cross Charm

$52.00

2 jewelry materials
Pearl Teardrop Charm
Pearl Teardrop Charm
New

Pearl Teardrop Charm

$54.00

2 jewelry materials
Statement Mother of Pearl Martha's Vineyard Island Charm
Statement Mother of Pearl Martha's Vineyard Island Charm
New

Statement Mother of Pearl Martha's Vineyard Island Charm

$62.00

2 jewelry materials
Mother of Pearl Sea Turtle Charm
Mother of Pearl Sea Turtle Charm
New

Mother of Pearl Sea Turtle Charm

$42.00

2 jewelry materials
Rainbow Striped Enamel Martha's Vineyard Island with tiny red heart charm on white background in 14k gold vermeil
Rainbow Striped Enamel Martha's Vineyard Island with tiny red heart charm on white background in sterling silver
New

Rainbow Enamel Martha's Vineyard Charm w/ Heart

from $58.00

2 jewelry materials
Pink Fish Charm
Pink Fish Charm
New

Pink Fish Charm

$42.00

2 colors
Feather Charm, Mother of Pearl
Feather Charm, Mother of Pearl
New

Feather Charm, Mother of Pearl

$52.00

2 jewelry materials
Statement Scallop Shell Charm, Mother of Pearl
Statement Scallop Shell Charm, Mother of Pearl
New

Statement Scallop Shell Charm, Mother of Pearl

$72.00

2 jewelry materials
Statement Starfish Charm, Mother of Pearl
Starfish charm mother of pearl on delicate gold necklace on a womans neck
New

Statement Starfish Charm, Mother of Pearl

$62.00

2 jewelry materials
Mother of pearl starfish charm in gold fill
Mother of pearl starfish charm in sterling silver on white background
New

Starfish Charm, Mother of Pearl

$42.00

2 jewelry materials
statement abalone shell charm gold fill on white background
Abalone Shell Statement Charm
Sold out

Abalone Shell Statement Charm

$82.00

2 jewelry materials
coral and orange glass heart charm on white
Orange Coral Stripe Glass Heart Charm
New

Orange Coral Stripe Glass Heart Charm

$28.00

5 colors
Sky Blue Glass Heart Charm
Sky Blue Glass Heart Charm
New

Sky Blue Glass Heart Charm

$28.00

5 colors
Martha’s Vineyard Mother of Pearl Charm
Martha’s Vineyard Mother of Pearl Charm
New

Martha’s Vineyard Mother of Pearl Charm

from $72.00

2 jewelry materials
Clear Irridescent Fish Charm
Clear Irridescent Fish Charm
New

Clear Irridescent Fish Charm

$48.00

2 colors
Mother of Pearl Dove Charm
Mother of Pearl Dove Charm
New

Mother of Pearl Dove Charm

$48.00

2 jewelry materials
Mother of Pearl Faceted Teardrop Charm
Mother of Pearl Faceted Teardrop Charm
New

Mother of Pearl Faceted Teardrop Charm

$28.00

2 jewelry materials
Mother of Pearl Conch Shell Charm
Mother of Pearl Conch Shell Charm
New

Mother of Pearl Conch Shell Charm

$42.00

2 jewelry materials
Hematite Fish Charm
Hematite Fish Charm
New

Hematite Fish Charm

$28.00

2 jewelry materials
Hematite Heart Charm
Hematite Heart Charm
New

Hematite Heart Charm

$28.00

2 jewelry materials
Tiny Teal Fish Charm
Tiny Teal Fish Charm
New

Tiny Teal Fish Charm

$12.00

3 colors
Tiny Yellow Fish Charm
Tiny Yellow Fish Charm
New

Tiny Yellow Fish Charm

$12.00

3 colors
Gold Star of David pendant on a white background
Star of David Charm
New

Star of David Charm

from $32.00

2 jewelry materials
Pearl Snowman Charm
Pearl Snowman Charm
New

Pearl Snowman Charm

$28.00

2 jewelry materials
Initial Letter Charms
Initial Letter Charms
New

Initial Letter Charms

from $28.00

2 jewelry materials
Large Baroque Freshwater Pearl Charm, White
Large Baroque Freshwater Pearl Charm, White
New

Large Baroque Freshwater Pearl Charm, White

$120.00

2 jewelry materials
Starfish Charm
Starfish Charm

Starfish Charm

$28.00

2 jewelry materials
Petite Scallop Shell Charm
Petite Scallop Shell Charm
New

Petite Scallop Shell Charm

from $24.00

2 jewelry materials
Scallop Shell Charm
Scallop Shell Charm
New

Scallop Shell Charm

from $48.00

2 jewelry materials
Pink & Green Flower Disc Charm
Pink & Green Flower Disc Charm
New

Pink & Green Flower Disc Charm

$28.00

2 jewelry materials
Pink & Green Melon Charm
Pink & Green Melon Charm
New

Pink & Green Melon Charm

$28.00

2 jewelry materials
Turquoise Cross Charm
Turquoise Cross Charm
Sold out

Turquoise Cross Charm

$28.00

2 jewelry materials
Load more